Friday, December 7, 2007

Wittgenstein and Speech Act Theory

Although some speech act theorists have denied any real connection between their own work and Wittgenstein’s, anyone who reads essays about speech act theory and then Philosophical Investigations will undoubtedly be struck by the similarities between the two ideas about language. Both begin by rejecting the idea that language can do nothing but state facts about the world; instead, they believe that language has many different uses in human activity. Given these significant similarities, I would like to explore the way in which Austin’s notion of felicitous and infelicitous speech acts might clarify Wittgenstein’s thoughts about language.

For Austin, utterances cannot simply be analyzed as either true or false because not all utterances make claims about the world. Thus, he suggests that it is better to analyze utterances as felicitous or infelicitous instead: felicitous utterances are those that succeed in performing the actions that they attempt, while infelicitous utterances are those that fail. Speech acts can become infelicitous for a variety of reasons, including the fact that they are performed in an improper context, the custom to which the appeal is not in place, and they are performed insincerely, in the absence of the proper intentions.

It is clear in Wittgenstein’s writings that the way in which a word is used determines its meaning. However, sometimes it is hard to know whether any use of a word that an individual might invent would then become a part of the word’s meaning, or if there has to be a certain number of individuals using the word in a new way in order for that new use to become a part of the meaning.

I think that Austin’s notion of infelicitous speech acts could really clear up this ambiguity in Wittgenstein because it allows us to talk about people using words in uncustomary ways without having to wonder whether their uncustomary use is an expansion of the meaning of the word. When someone uses a word in a new way, it is as if she is appealing to a custom that does not exist: there is no custom in which she can ground her use of the word, so the action that she is seeking to perform through her utterance fails, thereby rendering her speech infelicitous. Similarly, if someone were to use a word in the wrong context, we could describe her utterance as infelicitous instead of having to wonder whether we should allow that new use into the meaning.

I do not mean to suggest here that Wittgenstein is incapable of dealing with this issue within his own ideas—because there are more Wittgensteinian ways of addressing it—but I think that the analysis provided by Austin is a much clearer and less ambiguous way of solving the problem because it helps us understand exactly when we are justified in saying that some use of a word is illegitimate.

35 comments:

BF said...

And yet, sometimes a first novel use of a word may well be felicitous...

Anonymous said...

I had typed up a comment, but the Internet ate it. {sigh}

The upshot: what's bothering you is unclear without examples. Both Wittgenstein and Austin provide example after example to show what is their philosophical interest and in what kinds of cases their criticisms / solutions apply.

Austin's talk of in/felicitous speech acts is quite different from the case of introducing new words into a language. In any case, "It is clear in Wittgenstein’s writings that the way in which a word is used determines its meaning" is probably a source of your confusion, as Wittgenstein does not asssert this. At best, he suggests something like this as a definition of the word "meaning" (e.g., PI 43), which neither that all words work this way, nor that such a "definition" would be helpful in all cases. If you start working on specific examples, this will likely become clearer.

Much more detailed analyses of Wittgenstein's investigations into "meaning" are available at my blog.

Anonymous said...

Good post.

Unknown said...

Here's an interesting interview on Wittgenstein with John Searle who has done some important work on Speech Acts.

Anonymous said...

great post. I would love to follow you on twitter.

Anonymous said...

i'm new... hope to register around more time after time!

Anonymous said...

hi all
http://www.tor.com/community/users/thinquisalci1978
http://www.tor.com/community/users/tkuladlina1971
http://www.tor.com/community/users/nerocithi1989
http://www.tor.com/community/users/bardepofull1978
http://www.tor.com/community/users/moahuntfiwolf1981

Ty of Male Enhancement Pills said...

This is a very significant post indeed.. Keep share...

Anonymous said...

Look at your options; do your homework; and, over time, see where your efforts take you lumigan o Syntha-6
8-Wash your mane when it needs to be washed using gentle shampoos and conditionersRemember that everyone's hair grows at different rates but in all cases good care tips like I have just shown you will help make it grow even faster buy cymbalta cost Depression is a stupid reason to die when you are under 20 even if life seems to be over!
You need not spend fortunes for whitening, as there are many affordable products and treatments that can alter the color of your teeth for the better Viagra for women price However, some people don't really care if it's addictive or not
Most people in the gym, even the really serious one's, are much more interested in gaining muscle mass and burning fat than they are about getting seriously strong iressa To do that, focus on flushing the toxins out of your body by remaining hydrated
Use it or lose it -- this applies especially to your sex life Mobic online uk Also, you will have to take into consideration that it took you nine months to put on that amount of weight and it should take you nine months to get rid of it

Anonymous said...

[url=http://cialisonlinehere.com/#zqygr]cheap cialis online[/url] - buy cheap cialis , http://cialisonlinehere.com/#bmefj buy cialis online

Anonymous said...

Вкусненькое онлайн [url=http://aftertube.net.ua/tags/Pickup/]Pickup[/url] Порно онлайн : [url=http://aftertube.net.ua/tags/%EF%E0%EF%EE%E9/]папой[/url]
только 18+!

Anonymous said...

Most commonly the bars are steel, either onehalf inch or fiveeighths inch in diameter. zywall router. In commercial building, retrofitting caters as the substantial reducer of energy bills and maintenance cost thereby maximizing the ratio of savings. vpn it manchester

Anonymous said...

While a good network monitoring software not just keeps you updated about problems on a particular network, it tweaks your settings to find the optimal setup of the network. That's why, it is necessary to have an access to a best car finance deals. openvpn route delay. Some homeowners use this power first in the evenings before switching to utility supplied power to lower their energy bills even further. I will explain that later in another article., vpn mpls multicast. And when they found, it is often too late. unlock proxy

Anonymous said...

If you have been writing short articles for companies, maybe it is time you learned about writing sales letters or even ebooks., vpn windows 7 unavailable device missing. The greatest of all these needs are the computing needs. It may be very stressful and time consuming. configuring vpn in windows 2000. They feature multiple complications. vpn router win2k server nicht durchgeroutet

Anonymous said...

These binaural beats are very beneficial for the ones who meditate., vpn purdue. A contract finished among people who are in dissimilar countries is officially legitimate when it satisfies the official needs of applicable law or law of one of these countries. An additional excellent way of avoiding emotional tension will be to steer clear of those that pull you down. wireless software free download. If you need help setting up lists of keywords and figuring out which ones are going to work for you, you can find the resources that you need online to help you get started. vpn server configuration for ios devices

Anonymous said...

Our collection of practice exams questions is the most comprehensive and detailed. connect vpn mac. From clearing out the wasted space to getting cash quickly for the jewelry’s gold value, it’s a great way to bring in unexpected funds. vpn port in firewall

Anonymous said...

It explains why so many countries rich in natural resources are very poor. True to his sentiments, time is an indispensable testimony of change and movement and it is a watch that reminds us of the passing of precious time. www smile adsl. It is one of the things that keep people from all walks of life and from all corners of the world busy. It is a specialist in offering unbiased,efficient and reliable specialist financial advice to professionals from different niche including,solicitors, barristers, accountants, opticians,vets, pharmacists, chartered engineers, chartered surveyors,teachers and lecturers., ntp server not reachable. The principle is simple; the more people you get to view the product, the more product sales especially when the product is good. lymphadema network

Anonymous said...

However, there are some features that should be available in a forum to be regarded as a good forum. Go along the bandwagon and blog about your website. windows server environment pdf. The dual coverup has been the rage beacuase of its diversity. Christmas holiday gift baskets, gifts and care packages filled with chocolates, food, fruit, nuts, candy, cookies and keepsakes., kyota protocol. However, this unenviable chore can be made easier by handling the difficult areas, such as a closet, first. turn on computer from network

Anonymous said...

The cleaning practice generally starts with cleaning the house furniture like carpeting and tables. snap 1100 server. As a parent or a caregiver you will be more effective in raising an emotionally stable child by learning how to assist them in overcoming the unhealthy thought patterns that can result from rejection. beim herstellen einer verbindung mit sql server 2005

Anonymous said...

Other factors such as nutrition and rest also play a role, but height increasing exercises are especially important later in life if you're unhappy with being short. xfre client de. Hence one can easily commute to the other parts of the city. server version 099 b

Anonymous said...

Unlike advertising flyers though, brochures seem more credible and detailed since typically it is printed in higher quality. aioe server

Anonymous said...

On the first weeks of tutorial things might get pretty messy and quite difficult. Your readers will appreciate your honesty. . exchange mastering mastering microsoft server. So many people start joining the 000130 exam. It is also particularly interesting to see that some domestic animals have their close companions in the wild life category., to find a private lender. Cockroaches have a preference for the warmer areas of your home such as the kitchen, under the sink, the hot water system and behind the stove. map network cz

Anonymous said...

Definitely, the health of home is important of these reasons. Some of these inputs include oil and oil products that lead to an increase in the cost of production if their prices are increased by oil exporting countries; the cost of production caused by high input prices is therefore a major disadvantage toward the development of the industrial sector in developing countries. remote sex. Another example, woolen clothes have a seasonal market in warm countries but have great market all round the year in the cold regions or countries. Finally ask about the following., vpn power. What you merely need to do is hang it at a place where the students and parents can read the message. internet graphics server

Anonymous said...

clomid cd 5-9 | http://clomiddiscount.webs.com/#24755 - buy clomid no rx, when does clomid make you ovulate

Anonymous said...

how many cycles of clomid before you get pregnant | clomid cost - where to buy clomid online safely, clomid and hcg

Anonymous said...

how many mg of clomid should i take | [url=http://ordergenericclomid.webs.com/#86355]clomid no prescription needed[/url] - where to buy clomid online, voqz when to start clomid

Anonymous said...

[url=http://buyadderallonline.webs.com/]buy adderall xr online[/url]
[url=http://buyadderallonline.webs.com/buy-ritalin-online]best place buy ritalin online[/url]
[url=http://buyadderallonline.webs.com/buy-methadone-online]order methadone online no prescription[/url]
[url=http://buyadderallonline.webs.com/buy-oxycontin-online]how to buy oxycontin legally[/url]
[url=http://buyadderallonline.webs.com/buy-concerta-online]how to buy concerta[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.formspring.me/hmarket]buy lorazepam 2mg[/url]
[url=http://www.formspring.me/fshop]buy nitrazepam in the uk[/url]
[url=http://www.formspring.me/nmarket]do people buy prozac recreationally[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.formspring.me/sjshop]purchase Amlodipin[/url] buy norvasc amlodipine 5 mg generic [url=http://www.formspring.me/hjshop]can you buy ibuprofen in singapore[/url] purchase ibuprofen cream [url=http://www.formspring.me/kmarket]buy ultracod online[/url] buy ultracod online [url=http://www.formspring.me/hshop]can you buy dihydrocodeine over counter[/url] buy dihydrocodeine topix [url=http://www.formspring.me/llshop]can you buy paracetamol at 16[/url] buy paracetamol online [url=http://www.formspring.me/xcshop]buy azur online[/url] buy azur online [url=http://www.formspring.me/kshop]buy tramadol overnight delivery[/url] buy tramadol online australia [url=http://www.formspring.me/dshop]where to purchase codeine cough syrup[/url] order codeine promethazine syrup

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.formspring.me/HeikkiBarry]buy claritine online[/url] [url=http://www.formspring.me/SuomalTyler]telfast to buy[/url] [url=http://www.formspring.me/PontusRojas]where to buy clarinase in singapore[/url] [url=http://www.formspring.me/TiihonenBallard]buy cetirizine pseudoephedrine[/url] [url=http://www.formspring.me/TimonenDoyle]order Tavegil[/url] [url=http://www.formspring.me/VeliHarrell]can you buy zyrtec in canada[/url] [url=http://www.formspring.me/TenoiWoodward]buy anafranil online uk[/url] [url=http://www.formspring.me/ViiniRasmussen]order amitriptyline no prescription[/url] [url=http://www.formspring.me/ViljakainDavid]prozac buy europe[/url] [url=http://www.formspring.me/SulanderMercer]buy zoloft overnight delivery[/url]

Anonymous said...

Your рost οffers confiгmed useful
to me perѕonаlly. It’s гeally іnfогmativе аnd
yоu are nаturally quite educated in thiѕ fiеld.
Үоu hаve openeԁ up my eyeѕ in ordеr to vaгious thoughtѕ about thіs particulаг subject togethеr with intгiguіng anԁ ѕtrοng written content.
My blog :: viagra

Anonymous said...

The write-up ρгoviԁes establisheԁ useful to me persοnallу.

Іt’s eхtremelу іnformative and уou really are obviouѕly reаlly knοwlеdgeable іn this гegion.
Υou have got opеnеԁ my eye
to be ablе to ԁifferent viеws on thiѕ
κind of subject together with intriguing, notable and
solid aгticles.
Stop by my page - Buy Viagra Online

Anonymous said...

The write-up featurеs confirmed necessary to myѕelf.
It’s really helpful аnd yоu are cleагly rеаlly well-infоrmed in this aгea.

Yоu have pοpρed mу peгѕonаl faсе for you to varyіng opinion of
this particulаr matter using intriquing, notаble and stгong content.
Also visit my page :: buy Cialis

Anonymous said...

Your report offers cοnfirmed neceѕѕary to myself.
It’s quitе uѕeful and you arе cleаrly extremely educаted in
thіs fіeld. Yοu get openеd my own
eyes for уоu to different opinion of this kind of ѕubject matter
togethеr ωіth intereѕting and ѕolid content.
Also visit my web blog ... CIALIS

Anonymous said...

The article prοvides establishеd
hеlpful to me. Іt’s very educational anԁ you're simply clearly really well-informed of this type. You have opened up my personal eye to be able to numerous opinion of this specific topic using intriguing and solid written content.

Also visit my web-site; Cialis online